Spoiler Alert

Darren Goldstein/CBS

What To Know

The Sheriff Country Season 1 finale drops a couple shockers on Mickey.
Showrunner Matt Lopez breaks down those major moments, Mickey and Boone’s relationship, and more, plus looks ahead to Season 2.

A couple of bombshells are dropped on Mickey (Morena Baccarin) in the Sheriff Country finale, one that fans knew after the penultimate episode and another that ends the season and they likely didn’t see coming. TV Insider spoke with showrunner Matt Lopez about those and more. Warning: Spoilers for the Sheriff Country Season 1 finale ahead!

Mickey’s love interest, DEA agent Alec (Wes Chatham), is dirty, working for Miranda (Kelli O’Hara) and having already killed her son Rick (Matthew Finlan) after he tried to kill Mickey’s daughter Skye (Amanda Arcuri) in the penultimate episode. In the finale, Mickey becomes wise to just that, witnessing a conversation between Alec and Miranda that neither of them realize she has until it’s too late. By that time, Boone (Matt Lauria) has also picked up on Alec’s shady behavior, and they’ve put together a sting operation with Alec’s boss, Eva Santos (Rachel Ticotin).

They make Alec think that Mickey, too, is dirty and willing to go away with him, only to attempt to bring him in at his plane. In the process, Alec is shot, then, when they all let their guard down, shoots Boone before Santos kills him. (Boone is going to be OK.)

But the bigger shock comes for Mickey in the final moments as Santos tries to get her to agree to work with her and her father Wes (W. Earl Brown) to take down a Bulgarian cartel … only for Wes to walk in and be shocked to find that Santos is Mickey’s mother, whom they thought was dead. Mickey’s still absorbing that news when the finale ends.

Below, showrunner Matt Lopez breaks down the shocking finale and shares early Season 2 details. (Plus, read what Matt Lauria had to say about Mickey and Boone and his hopes going forward here.)

We have to start with that last scene because Mickey’s mom, I love the way that is played. So just talk about introducing her in this way and why didn’t she tell Mickey who she is?

Matt Lopez: We are told, I believe, if I’m not mistaken, as early as the Season 1 pilot, it’s pretty clear that Mickey’s mom, in her mind, is dead. And all season long, there are sprinkled little Easter eggs. And then as we come down the stretch of the season, we see Wes visiting the grave. We see Mickey telling Luna in Episode 118 sort of her origin story and how her mother died in the Edgewater County jail while awaiting trial. And then obviously, what we learn and what we will in Season 2 have to unpack is that is not true. Both Mickey and Wes do not know this incredible secret that Mickey’s mother remains alive to this day and in fact is the woman who has been called into Edgewater to investigate this level of corruption.

Darren Goldstein/CBS

One of the things we’ll unpack at the beginning of Season 2 is to what extent was Eva Santos trying to learn what kind of person her daughter is. She has been cut off from her daughter for years for reasons that we’ll get into and will become very clear. And I think the decision that she made all those years ago to leave Wes and Mickey, while it was a brutally hard decision and one that I think Eva has regrets about to this day, when the audience sees all the reasons that went into it, it’s not as simple as black and white. She was dealt a very bad hand of cards and she played it the best she could and believed she was doing what was best for her daughter. And we can question that decision and Mickey will question it.

Eva knew if she told Wes before Wes walked in that door, I think there’s no way he would’ve ever agreed to cooperate in this mission that the three of them are going to undertake at the top of Season 2 to take down this cartel. And so now, Mickey and Wes, not only are they being forced to work together — because of course they’re not in the greatest shape in their relationship either — are going to have to work together with the great love of Wes’ life and Mickey’s mother, who she long thought was dead as their handler. And all the family dynamics and turns that come from that, I think, are pretty delicious.

Eva, I think the audiences once they — I’ve been following a little bit sort of the online response to the character and people are like, “I hate her.” I think now we’ll really get to know her and we’ll really dimensionalize her. I think for example, Mickey, who has a lot of hostility toward her mother when the season starts, will have to acknowledge there’s certain aspects of Eva that are not only quite admirable but remind Mickey of herself and that makes for some just great sort of character storytelling.

Why make Alec dirty? Going back to Brandon’s murder, I loved that detail. And why kill him off? Did you ever consider letting him live?

We did consider letting him live. There were times on set, I’m like, “Damn, this Wes Chatham is so charming, and he’s so good on screen with Morena.” There were times where I was very, very tempted, but it felt like the right conclusion for the story.

He’s a man who — my favorite villains are the ones whose motivations and goals, at the end of the day, aren’t that different from the heroes, differences the lengths to which they will go to achieve them. I think I take Alec at his word, and Wes and I and Morena and I would have long discussions about this. He does love her. He loves her so much. He was willing to commit murder to help her family, to help her daughter. And that’s what he tells her. “I’m the only one who was looking out for you.” I mean, it’s really crazy, but it kind of makes sense at the same time. So I think he genuinely loved her and I think Mickey loved him.

Why was Mickey keeping what she realized about Alec to herself until Boone told her his theory? Was that to protect him? Was that her still figuring things out and she just didn’t want to bring anyone else in?

Yes, I think there’s a portion of that episode through acts one and two where she’s like, “I had to be sure.” She’s putting together this piece, but what about, wait, she saw in the mirror, it looked like he had a moment with Miranda, what is that? And it’s not until she gets together with Boone and Boone is like, “You’re not going to like this. I think this guy is dirty.” And then we see these two characters, Mickey and Boone, who all season long, there have been times there’s been this push-pull. We see once again like, “Oh yeah, what an amazing team.” When they are firing on all cylinders, they’re the greatest.
 

Darren Goldstein/CBS

Speaking of, what did you want to do with Mickey and Boone and the feelings there this season? Also, it seems like the finale could be setting up that maybe Mickey might be jealous going forward.

I think Mickey has to be asking herself, did I walk past a diamond to pick up a piece of coal? Boone confessed his love for her and that’s in [Episode] 18. And then in [Episode] 19, they have that moment in the file room where she says, “Look, I’d be lying if I said when we were deputies that I never…” And she sort of trails off, but it’s pretty clear. You can see on Lauria’s face, he thinks this is a confession of love and it is, but she’s like, “But I’m your boss now.” And she’s into Alec when she says that. Now, of course, that has blown up spectacularly

To put it mildly.

And I think there’s that look in the hospital room. She looks back and now Emmy Yorke [Jenny Raven], the medical examiner, is she a better fit for Boone? And I think Mickey is going to have to look inward and realize, have I made a mistake?

Yeah, but also she might not be in the best place for a relationship now and especially one with Boone. That’s the other thing to take into account, right?

That’s very true, although I don’t know if that woman would let that stop her. I don’t know. One of the great things about the character is — I love characters that are just amazing at their jobs but not so great in their real lives and that’s clearly Mickey. [Laughs.]

Travis (Christopher Gorham) seemingly has a new focus at the end of the season. Why is this the right path for him now? And I like that you have Skye part of that, too.

The Fraleys are like a founding family of Edgewater and the sense of community and history on this show, I think much more so than other procedurals, cop shows, whatever, it’s such an integral — the town is kind of a character in a way and Skye and Travis see themselves as guardians of that community and guardians of that company and are going to try and save it.

But I will say it will not be easy. We will find in the premiere of Season 2, the company’s under a huge cloud of investigation because of the stuff that Travis’s sister Miranda did. The DEA is investigating it. To what extent is Fraley Horizons a criminal enterprise? Did Skye know about it? Did Travis know about it? And so what they will find is that the promise that they made at the end of Season 1 to the employees of the company won’t be an easy one to keep.

So with that in mind, and also what you introduced that Mickey’s mom at the end of the finale, is there a time jump of any sort? Is Season 2 picking up soon after?

Without giving anything away, there’s a small time jump and then a sort of delicious catch-up of what we missed between literally the moment Wes said, “Mickey, this is your mother,” and where we catch up to Mickey. Some hours have gone by, and it’s really fun when we find out what happened in that little missing piece of time.
 

Darren Goldstein/CBS

Cassidy (Michele Weaver), despite what she says to Hank (Ian Quinlan) or Enrique Iglesias, which was hilarious, did seem to be thinking about quitting or at least thinking about her approach to the job and what she’s getting out of the job at this point. Did she just need to find something she felt would make the job worth it like she had by the end of the finale?

I think so. I think what she tells Hank is that she’s come back from the Blood Moon Killer episode, which obviously was a hugely emotional, impactful episode for her, both in terms of heartbreak in that she confirmed that her sister was murdered at the hands of this man, but also there was a redemptive quality because now at the end of Episode 15, it seems clear that Cassidy and her mother, there’s a path forward for them and the emotional healing that came as a result of that is so core to who Cassidy is. So now that she’s come back from this road trip, which was basically Michele needed to have her baby, she had her baby and now she’s back to us.

And I think she comes back at a time where she’s had time away and the ability to gain a little bit of perspective on the job and she comes back into this just awful case where Skye’s cousin tried to kill her and Wes’ betrayal and Alec Kane’s betrayal. And what she sees is what she responds to about this job is that healing aspect and the idea of these unsolved cases, these families that are awaiting and praying for the same kind of healing that Cassidy and her mother had and maybe even have given up hope that there might be a way to restore some of that hope, I think, is going to give Cassidy a real sense of drive and purpose in Season 2.

What else can you tease about Season 2 and can you say if all of the season’s regulars are returning?

All the regulars are returning and actually we’re adding some regulars as I think you probably know, Skye and Hank were elevated to regulars. So, yeah, it’s very much like the family that we’ve established, but of course we’re going to throw some new characters into the mix and some new dynamics to work out for all the characters and mainly for Mickey.

Mickey, her journey in Season 1 was all about, can I rebuild my family? In that pilot, if you think back to it, her relations are strained with her father who she hasn’t really spoken to in quite a while. Her relations are strained with Skye who has relapsed a number of times. Her relations are strained with Boone because he’s allowed himself to be put up for sheriff. And her relationship with Cassidy is strained because Cassidy is sleeping with Mickey’s ex-husband. And so all these pieces were frayed and over the course of the season they were restored. It wasn’t always pretty. It was fits and starts. Sometimes it was on step forward and two steps back, but I think it was largely successful.

In Season 2, Mickey doesn’t need to repair her family. She really needs to repair herself and she really needs to look inward and look in the mirror because she’s defined herself as a person who never had a mother and now she learns she does. And what does that mean for who she is and how she raises her family and how her relationship with Skye, her relationship with Wes, and so on. I think we’ve got, if anything, an even better journey for Mickey in Season 2 than we had in Season 1.

 
Related

Inside the ‘Fire Country’-‘Sheriff Country’ Crossover With Max Thierot & Matt Lauria (Exclusive)

What can you say about any conversations you’ve had about crossovers with Fire Country, like another two-parter or just the smaller ones? Because either way, they worked really well this season.

They did. And if it ain’t broke, Meredith… We’re going to do both. We’re going to do another big event where a story starts in Sheriff and it’s almost like a feature. It’s like one sprawling story with characters from both shows in each other’s shows. But we’re also going to do some of those fun crosses, these kind of one-offs where you’re not expecting a character to show up. And obviously, there’s a familial relationship between Mickey and Sharon [Diane Farr], so that’s the natural place to go. But without naming names, I will say we are doing some crossovers — there’s going to be some characters from Fire who are going to appear on Sheriff who have never appeared on Sheriff before. And vice versa.

Are there any characters you’re especially looking forward to having interact more in Season 2?

I’ll tell you a fun one that we were just talking about the writers room today, and this could seem kind of random. I’m going to say Mickey and Hank. Mickey and Hank had some fun interactions in Season 1. There’s the episode in 14 where she basically tells him to stare at the wall. He’s fairly low down on the totem pole. She knows him for the kind of hothead he is. And in an early Season 2 episode, she’s going to have occasion to get to know him much better and she’s made certain assumptions about him that I think she’ll have to reassess. And I think it’s like a fun relationship that we didn’t unpack in a huge way in Season 1, but we’ll get those two crossing a little bit more in Season 2.

I need more of Bode and Boone together because what we got in the crossover was so, so good.

They’re great together. It’s like a buddy cop movie with those two. They brought out so much fun with each other and I don’t think you’re going to be disappointed, Meredith.

Sheriff Country, Season 2, Fall 2026, Fridays, 8/7c, CBS