In a festive announcement that has fans cheering, Hallmark Media has officially renewed the hit cozy mystery series Mistletoe Murders for a third season. The news, revealed on February 20, 2026, comes hot on the heels of Season 2’s dramatic finale, ensuring more holiday cheer mixed with suspense during the network’s beloved Countdown to Christmas event later this year.

Starring Sarah Drew (known for Grey’s Anatomy) as Emily Lane and Peter Mooney (from Rookie Blue) as Detective Sam Wilner, the series blends the wholesome romance and community spirit Hallmark is famous for with lighthearted whodunits set against a perpetual Christmas backdrop. Emily, a bubbly and optimistic owner of a year-round Christmas-themed store in the charming tourist town of Fletcher’s Grove, harbors a mysterious secret from her past. When murders inevitably strike during the holiday season, she teams up with the sharp, no-nonsense local detective Sam to crack the cases—often while sparks fly between them.

people.com

Sarah Drew’s Mistletoe Murders Renewed for Season 3 on Hallmark (Exclusive)

The show’s unique formula has proven irresistible: festive decorations, twinkling lights, and cozy small-town vibes serve as the perfect contrast to the occasional murder investigation. Emily’s go-getter personality and hidden depths make her an engaging amateur sleuth, while Sam’s professional demeanor and growing personal connection to Emily add romantic tension. As Hallmark Head of Programming Michelle Vicary noted, “Mistletoe Murders embodies so many of the elements viewers turn to Hallmark for: romance, community and Christmas wrapped within a cozy mystery.”

Season 2 wrapped with a major cliffhanger on November 27, 2025, leaving Emily and Sam facing serious trouble in Fletcher’s Grove just as their relationship appeared to be progressing. Sarah Drew expressed excitement in an exclusive interview, saying she “can’t wait to resolve that giant cliffhanger” and continue exploring the characters’ journeys. Production for Season 3 is slated to begin later in 2026, with episodes expected to premiere during Hallmark’s annual holiday programming slate, likely in late fall or early winter.

harltonempire.com

Peter Mooney on “Mistletoe Murders” Season 2: Detective Sam Wilner, Small-Town Secrets & Holiday Intrigue

The renewal highlights the series’ strong fanbase and solid ratings. Adapted from an Audible Original series (originally starring Cobie Smulders), Mistletoe Murders has carved out its niche in Hallmark’s expanding slate of scripted mysteries. Viewers appreciate how it delivers murder investigations without veering into dark territory—crimes are solved with clever deduction, heartwarming moments, and plenty of holiday spirit. Episodes often feature seasonal themes like Christmas feasts, store decorations, and community events gone awry due to foul play.

hallmarkchannel.com

About | Mistletoe Murders

Stars Drew and Mooney have been vocal about their appreciation for the show and its audience. Both shared joyful posts on social media upon the renewal, with Drew declaring “Merry merry MISTLETOE MURDERS SEASON 3 babyyyyyyy!!!” Fans echoed the enthusiasm, flooding comments with excitement over more Emily-Sam team-ups and festive sleuthing.

The series also benefits from strong supporting characters and recurring town residents who add depth to the investigations and romantic subplots. While full casting details for Season 3 remain under wraps, expect familiar faces to return alongside potential new suspects and allies in Fletcher’s Grove.

fantasylandnews.com

Sarah Drew & Peter Mooney Announced Mistletoe Murders Season 3 on Hallmark – Fantasy Land News

As Hallmark continues to evolve its programming—mixing traditional romances with light mysteries like this one—Mistletoe Murders stands out as a fresh take on holiday entertainment. It proves the network isn’t afraid to add a dash of intrigue to its signature sugarplum sweetness. With Emily’s secret still unfolding and Sam determined to uncover the truth (both in cases and in her heart), Season 3 promises more cozy chills and romantic thrills under the mistletoe.

All episodes of Seasons 1 and 2 are currently streaming on Hallmark+, giving newcomers plenty of time to catch up before the next round of yuletide mysteries arrives.