A VOICE WAS ALLEGEDLY COMMANDING HER… NOW TH...

A VOICE WAS ALLEGEDLY COMMANDING HER… NOW THE COURT IS HEARING WHAT MAY HAVE BEEN HAPPENING INSIDE LINDSAY CLANCY’S MIND..! – EXPERT TESTIMONY REVEALS CLAIM OF COMMAND HALLUCINATION WHEN HER THREE CHILDREN WERE K-ILLED.

Play Video: Heartbreak for dead hiker's family when they're mistakenly told she's alive

Heartbreak for dead hiker’s family when they’re mistakenly told she’s alive

Play Video: Woman, 38, accused of pretending to be 12yo child to get couple to look after her for a year

Woman, 38, accused of pretending to be 12yo child to get couple to look after her for a year

Play Video: Knife thug chases man with huge machete outside busy nightclub

Knife thug chases man with huge machete outside busy nightclub

Play Video: Flooding and mudslides, linked to El Niño, hits Chile

Flooding and mudslides, linked to El Niño, hits Chile

Play Video: Harry and Meghan return to 'lion's den' prepared, says royal analyst

Harry and Meghan return to ‘lion’s den’ prepared, says royal analyst

Play Video: Hampshire man flashes pistol at lorry driver after 'minor traffic incident'

Hampshire man flashes pistol at lorry driver after ‘minor traffic incident’

Play Video: Horse-drawn funeral for teenager Alex McCarthy killed in wrong-way crash

Horse-drawn funeral for teenager Alex McCarthy killed in wrong-way crash

Play Video: Burnham: Harry and Meghan moving back to UK is a 'private matter'

Burnham: Harry and Meghan moving back to UK is a ‘private matter’

Play Video: Students found 'hanging out of the windows' after Swedish school sword attack

Students found ‘hanging out of the windows’ after Swedish school sword attack

Play Video: Thousands of dead fish wash up on Cape Town beaches

Thousands of dead fish wash up on Cape Town beaches

Play Video: 'I can go for lunch with them': Locals near Althorp House hopeful for Harry and Meghan's return

‘I can go for lunch with them’: Locals near Althorp House hopeful for Harry and Meghan’s return

Play Video: Met Police discover tunnelling thieves trying to break into Tooting jewellery shop

Met Police discover tunnelling thieves trying to break into Tooting jewellery shop

Play Video: Moment supercars are petrol bombed outside Birmingham wedding venue

Moment supercars are petrol bombed outside Birmingham wedding venue

Play Video: Vietnam Airlines Boeing 787 barely makes it into the air after massive tailstrike

Vietnam Airlines Boeing 787 barely makes it into the air after massive tailstrike

Play Video: Moment man calls police because Tesco wouldn't refund his gin and tonic

Moment man calls police because Tesco wouldn’t refund his gin and tonic

Play Video: St Pancras station evacuated after 'controlled explosion'

St Pancras station evacuated after ‘controlled explosion’

Play Video: Smoke billows after fire breaks out in south east London

Smoke billows after fire breaks out in south east London

Play Video: Lindsay Clancy breaks-down after hearing testimony during triple-murder trial

Lindsay Clancy breaks-down after hearing testimony during triple-murder trial

Play Video: Remains of Hounslow house after fire which killed one and hospitalised eight in west London

Remains of Hounslow house after fire which killed one and hospitalised eight in west London

Play Video: Council use tractor to kick up dust and force traveller caravans out

Council use tractor to kick up dust and force traveller caravans out

Play Video: POV of Deptford fire from Southeastern train passing right through it

POV of Deptford fire from Southeastern train passing right through it

Play Video: Large police response after man shot dead ambushed in his car near Newham

Large police response after man shot dead ambushed in his car near Newham

Play Video: Woman left traumatised after allegedly being drugged and forced to wet herself by French civil servant

Woman left traumatised after allegedly being drugged and forced to wet herself by French civil servant

Play Video: CCTV emerges of moment helicopter crashes in Greece killing Brits

CCTV emerges of moment helicopter crashes in Greece killing Brits

Play Video: Reverend says Jews 'practice black magic' and 'r*tards turn to Islam' in online videos

Reverend says Jews ‘practice black magic’ and ‘r*tards turn to Islam’ in online videos

Play Video: Deptford fire rages on, as seen from resident's window

Deptford fire rages on, as seen from resident’s window

Play Video: Moment witness in Tupac murder trial gestures for lawyer to stop talking

Moment witness in Tupac murder trial gestures for lawyer to stop talking

Play Video: Rats and mice cause havoc in housing association

Rats and mice cause havoc in housing association

Play Video: Philadelphia police looking for man in terrifying Chucky-style mask who left jogger injured

Philadelphia police looking for man in terrifying Chucky-style mask who left jogger injured

Play Video: Police: Three people from same family die after getting into trouble off Shoreham coast

Police: Three people from same family die after getting into trouble off Shoreham coast

Play Video: Donald Trump chases small child across the stage in Las Vegas

Donald Trump chases small child across the stage in Las Vegas

Play Video: Car, somehow, smashes through top floor of house in Kent

Car, somehow, smashes through top floor of house in Kent

Play Video: Everyone's asking what's up with Trump's butt after last public appearance

Everyone’s asking what’s up with Trump’s butt after last public appearance

Play Video: 'We are all pleased' to see Harry and Meghan return to UK, says Lucy Powell

‘We are all pleased’ to see Harry and Meghan return to UK, says Lucy Powell

Play Video: Woman fired after posting TikTok complaining about being a Junior lawyer

Woman fired after posting TikTok complaining about being a Junior lawyer

Play Video: 'Quiet!': Trump uses innocent 10-year-old to gang up on female reporter

‘Quiet!’: Trump uses innocent 10-year-old to gang up on female reporter

Play Video: Dramatic moment women jumps out of 11th storey of burning building

Dramatic moment women jumps out of 11th storey of burning building

Play Video: Russia's Lavrov warns UK faces 'ensuing consequences' for supplying drones to Ukraine

Russia’s Lavrov warns UK faces ‘ensuing consequences’ for supplying drones to Ukraine

Play Video: Drunk driver who mowed down bride on wedding night whines in new arrest footage to call dad

Drunk driver who mowed down bride on wedding night whines in new arrest footage to call dad

Play Video: Count Binface has best possible response when asked what his Americanised political beliefs are

Count Binface has best possible response when asked what his Americanised political beliefs are

Play Video: Phonecall captures moment IDF kills Palestinian girl's, 5, relatives before she meets same fate

Phonecall captures moment IDF kills Palestinian girl’s, 5, relatives before she meets same fate

Lindsay Clancy, the mother accused of murdering her three children, was suffering from a ‘command hallucination’ at the time, her trial has heard.

Clancy, 36, is said to have planned the killings of Callan, Dawson and Cora Clancy, whose bodies were found in the basement of the family home in Duxbury, Massachusetts, in January 2023.

She does not deny killing them, but her lawyers argue she should not be held criminally responsible for their deaths because she was suffering with postpartum psychosis.

Her trial, which has captivated millions in the US and beyond, heard from the final defence witnesses on Friday, including Phillip Resnick, a forensic psychiatrist and expert in filicide – the killing of a child by a parent.

symbol

00:02

02:24

Read More

Resnick told jurors he spent hours interviewing Clancy and believes she was ‘clearly psychotic’ at the time of the killings.

The expert, who also testified for the defence in the infamous trial of Andrea Yates for drowning her five children in 2001, described several categories of filicide, including killings involving abuse.

Others involve psychosis or what he calls ‘altruistic’ filicide — a killing committed ‘out of love rather than hostility’.

He said he found Clancy’s case involved both of the latter categories, but he didn’t find evidence of abuse.

Defendant Lindsay Clancy watches as her attorney Kevin Reddington prepares to interview a witness in Plymouth Superior Court, in Plymouth, U.S., August 21, 2026. Mark Jarret Chavous/Pool via REUTERS
Lindsay Clancy watches as her attorney Kevin Reddington prepares to interview a witness in Plymouth Superior Court (Picture: Reuters)

15450549 Lindsay Clancy social media - photos show Lindsay, her husband and their 3 children. Surviving child is pixelated. TO GO WITH: 11677093 Two children, aged five and three, are found dead and in Massachusetts home and eight-month-old baby is treated for injuries in hospital - as cops investigate woman as suspect after she jumped out of window when officers arrived
A photo posted to social media shows Clancy, her husband and two of their children

Supporters of Lindsay Clancy stand outside Plymouth Superior Court where Clancy is on trial for the death of her three children, Thursday, Aug. 20, 2026., in Plymouth, Mass. (AP Photo/Josh Reynolds )
Supporters of Lindsay Clancy stand outside Plymouth Superior Court (Picture: AP)

Resnick said Clancy suffered from severe depression, showed evidence consistent with bipolar disorder and reported hearing a voice commanding her to kill her children.

‘My opinion is that Ms Clancy was, due to her mental disease, unable to conform her conduct to the requirements of the law on the day that she took the lives of her children’, he told jurors.

‘It was a matter where she was just following the command rather than being able to make any decision to do it or not.’

‘It was like she was a puppet and someone else was pulling the strings’

He added: ‘A hallucination is simply hearing a voice, and the voice can be benign or it can be more malignant.

‘About a third of voices are called command hallucinations. That is an instruction to do something, and the majority of those commands are benign. It might be “open a window”, “get a glass of water”.

‘It might be something much more ominous, such as to kill oneself or harm someone else. Those are dangerous command hallucinations.

‘Now, in Ms Clancy’s case, she had not only a command hallucination on the day that she killed her children – she had what is known as a delusion of influence.

‘That is, not only did she hear a command, but she felt that her body was taken over by an external force, where she were in a dream state and did not have control of her own body.

‘It was almost like she was a puppet and someone else was pulling the strings.’

A screen shows defense attorney Kevin Reddington as he interviews witness Phillip Resnick, on remote feed, from Cleveland Ohio, during Lindsay Clancy's murder trial, in Plymouth, U.S., August 21, 2026. Mark Jarret Chavous/Pool via REUTERS
Defense attorney Kevin Reddington interviews witness Phillip Resnick (Picture: Pool via AP)

Resnick said Clancy had a delusional belief that if social services took the children or if she killed herself, her children would suffer without her.

He said she believed that they would be better off dying with her and going to heaven.

‘She believed that she was doing what was right for her children,’ he said.

‘In her mind, she believed that she would be doing her children a favour by having them go to heaven with her rather than remain on earth without her doing the mothering.’

Prosecutors say Clancy contrived to get her husband out of the house on the day of the killings by sending him to collect some takeout food and pick up medication for one of the kids.

He arrived home to find Clancy on the floor, with a 911 call picking up his horrified reaction as he goes inside and finds the bodies of their three children: ‘She killed the kids!’

‘She was begging for help’

Clancy has observed her trial from the confines of a wheelchair after she was paralysed from jumping out of the window following the killings.

Family members, including her mother, former mother-in-law and sister, gave evidence earlier this week saying she had mental health struggles and described thoughts of ‌harming herself and her three children in the months before she killed them.

‘She was begging for help,’ Clancy’s former mother-in-law, Susan Clancy, told jurors of the ‘very nurturing, very loving’ mother.

Paula Musgrove, mother to defendant Lindsay Clancy, observes the trial on Friday, August 21, 2026, after testifying a few days prior at Plymouth Superior Court on Friday, August 21, 2026. (Mark Chavous /The Enterprise via AP, Pool)
Clancy’s mother Paula Musgrove observes the trial on Friday (Picture: Mark Chavous/Pool The Enterprise/AP)

Clancy’s mother, Paula Musgrove, said her daughter had loved her children ​and was dedicated to them.

But she said that starting in October 2022, she began to frequently stay at Clancy’s home after receiving a text message from her saying: ‘It’s just really scary and I don’t want to be alone.’

Clancy told her then-husband, Patrick Clancy, and Musgrove in December 2022 ‘she had thoughts of harming ​the children’, Musgrove said.

The couple divorced after the killings.

Allison Osga, Clancy’s sister, testified that around that time she learned ​Clancy was ‘feeling numb’, having suicidal thoughts and seeking treatment.

In late December, ‘she told me she had had suicidal ideation every day for a month’, Osga ‌testified.

But under ⁠questioning by a prosecutor, Osga, who is a social worker and by law required to report suspected harm to children, said she never had enough concern about the children’s safety in January 2023 to file a report about her sister.

‘There’s no reason she couldn’t tell right from wrong’

After the defence rested its case, prosecutors began calling rebuttal witnesses.

Dr Avram Mack agreed that Clancy suffered from a major depressive episode but said he found no evidence of mania or hypomania to support a bipolar diagnosis — or of psychosis — leading up to the killings.

Prosecution rebuttal witness Avram Mack answers questions from the witness stand during Lindsay Clancy's murder trial, in Plymouth, U.S., August 21, 2026. Mark Jarret Chavous/Pool via REUTERS
Prosecution rebuttal witness Dr Avram Mack answers questions from the witness stand during Lindsay Clancy’s murder trial (Picture: Pool via Reuters)

Mack said Clancy recounted the killings to him, saying she heard a loud male voice telling her to kill the children so she could kill herself.

She recalled strangling the children and saying ‘go to God’ as she did so, he told jurors.

Trending Now

Mack said Clancy was experiencing severe mental illness when she killed her children but that it was a continuation of the depression she had experienced for months in which she was able to control impulses and distinguish right from wrong.

He said: ‘There’s no reason that psychosis in and of itself inhibits a person’s ability to know right from wrong.’

Clancy faces life in prison without parole if convicted of first-degree murder.

If found not guilty due to lack of criminal responsibility, or by reason of insanity, she would be ​committed to a state psychiatric hospital ​for evaluation.

Disclaimer: This story is fictional and created for entertainment purposes only. Any names, characters, places, or events are fictitious or used fictitiously. No real person or organization is intended to be portrayed.

Related Articles