New evidence challenges the original narrative and raises serious questions about high-performance vehicle safety.

PUEBLA DE SANABRIA, SPAIN — What was first thought to be a case of speeding gone wrong has now taken a tragic and deeply unsettling turn. On July 3, 2025, Liverpool star Diogo Jota and his brother, André Silva, were killed in a horrific crash on Spain’s A-52 highway. Initial reports cited excessive speed and driver error. But weeks later, Spanish authorities have uncovered new evidence suggesting that the real culprit was not behind the wheel — but beneath it.

❗ A Hidden Killer: The Tire Defect

After extensive forensic analysis, investigators determined that the Lamborghini Huracán’s left rear tire suffered a critical manufacturing flaw. The defect, which compromised the internal structure of the tire, made it particularly vulnerable at high speeds. Police now believe that a catastrophic blowout occurred during a routine overtaking maneuver, triggering the chain of events that ended in tragedy.

Although preliminary estimates suggested the car was traveling at over 120 km/h, experts now say that speed may not have been the primary cause of the crash.

🚛 Eyewitnesses Dispute Speeding Claims

In a compelling twist, two lorry drivers who were traveling on the same stretch of road have come forward, challenging the official assumption that the car was being driven recklessly. Both described the Lamborghini as “controlled” and “not aggressive.” They also pointed to poor road conditions — including potholes and surface erosion — as a likely contributor to the tire failure.

Combined with the forensic findings, these eyewitness accounts have dramatically reframed the incident from one of driver recklessness to a tragic failure of both machine and infrastructure.

🚨 A Disturbing Recall History

Adding to the controversy is the growing spotlight on Lamborghini’s recall history. Models manufactured between 2021 and 2022, including the Huracán line, were subject to multiple tire-related recalls. Safety experts now question whether these recalls were handled adequately — and whether Diogo Jota’s vehicle was one of the affected models.

Advocacy groups are calling for an industry-wide investigation into how performance car manufacturers monitor, report, and rectify safety issues — especially when lives are at stake.

💔 A Nation in Mourning

The tragedy has left a gaping wound in the football world and beyond. Thousands gathered in Gondomar, Portugal, to say goodbye to Diogo and André. Liverpool FC officials, teammates, and Portugal’s football elite stood side by side with grieving fans.

Cristiano Ronaldo, one of the many to share their sorrow, posted a heartbreaking tribute:
“It doesn’t make sense. Rest in peace, Diogo and André.”

At Anfield and across Portugal, mourners continue to leave scarves, jerseys, and personal messages in tribute — a silent reminder of the deep impact the young star had on millions.

🧾 What Comes Next?

The final police report, expected to be submitted to the Puebla de Sanabria district court, will reportedly emphasize that the crash was the result of a deadly mix of manufacturing failure, substandard road conditions, and moderate driving — a far cry from the initial assumptions of reckless behavior.

This case is already sparking a larger conversation about road safety, automotive transparency, and the systemic issues that allow such oversights to go unchallenged.

As investigations continue, one thing remains painfully clear: this was not just a tragic accident — it was a preventable one.