JURORS heard horrifying new details in court as the former FedEx driver who killed seven-year-old Athena Strand faces a decision on whether he should live or die.
The sentencing phase heard video and audio from inside the delivery van, where prosecutors say Tanner Horner abducted the little girl after stopping at her home.

Tanner Horner sang Jingle Bell Rock as he strangled seven-year-old Athena Strand to deathCredit: NBC 5 News

Horner, 34, pleaded guilty on April 7 to capital murder and aggravated kidnapping in Athena’s 2022 killingCredit: AP

Horner had been delivering a Christmas package to the family’s home in Paradise when Athena ended up inside his truckCredit: Facebook/ Maitlyn Presley Gandy
Jurors were told Horner sang Jingle Bell Rock as he strangled Athena to death in the back of the van.
In Fort Worth, Texas, the jury is now deciding whether Horner should be sentenced to death or spend the rest of his life in prison without parole.
Horner, 34, pleaded guilty on April 7 to capital murder and aggravated kidnapping in Athena’s 2022 killing.
The case then moved straight into the punishment phase, with prosecutors laying out the final moments of Athena’s life.
Jury sobs as footage shows Athena Strand asking killer chilling last question
Court heard Horner had been delivering a Christmas package to the family’s home in Paradise when Athena ended up inside his truck.
That package contained Barbie dolls meant as a Christmas gift for the seven-year-old.
Video shown to jurors captured Horner pulling up to the home and later picking Athena up and placing her inside the van before shutting the door.
Before the camera was covered, Athena could be heard asking where he was taking her.
Jurors then heard audio from inside the truck after the lens was blocked.
Athena asked, “Are you a kidnapper, and begged to go home as the exchange grew more frightening.”
NBC DFW reported jurors also heard Horner threaten to hurt her if she screamed.
Another chilling moment came when he told the child, “You’re really pretty. You know that?”
Jurors later heard him tell Athena to take her shirt off while she said no and asked for her mother.
The recording continued with crying, screaming and banging, leaving jurors visibly shaken in court.
Athena’s family chose to leave the courtroom before the video was played.
Prosecutors say Horner’s earlier claim that Athena’s death was an accident was a lie, arguing footage showed she was conscious and moving inside the truck.
Fox 4 reported Horner had told investigators he accidentally hit Athena with the van, panicked, kidnapped her and later strangled her.
Medical testimony in court said Athena died from blunt force trauma, smothering and strangulation.
Jurors also heard that male DNA was found on swabs from Athena’s sexual assault kit, while analysts also found blood under her fingernails and male DNA on her clothing.
The prosecution has rested its case after presenting the graphic van footage and forensic evidence.
The defense is pushing for life in prison instead of execution, citing Horner’s Asperger’s syndrome, other mental illnesses and claims of fetal alcohol and childhood lead exposure.

Maitlyn Gandy, Athena’s mother left the courtroom before the video of her daughter’s abduction was played for the juryCredit: AP

Medical testimony in court said Athena died from blunt force trauma, smothering and strangulationCredit: Facebook/Tanner L. Horner
News
A RUTHLESS BLOW: Kendrick Lamar plots to annihilate Drake’s hype right before the big reveal!
Kendrick Lamar had a busy 2025 and for most of 2026, he’s laid low. But lately, there’s been chatter around…
The final night of Cardi B’s tour gathered a stellar lineup of stars, making the stands explode and letting everyone forget the backstage dramas
Cardi B is taking the high road after an alleged backstage dispute nearly derailed her Atlanta tour stop. The rapper, 33, appeared…
Buckingham Palace officials have reportedly grown ‘deeply uncomfortable’ with the Sussexes’ recent maneuvers in Australia
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle spent four days in Australia last week (Image: Getty) Prince Harry and Meghan Markle returned to the States this…
Meghan faces a massive backlash for this ‘disgusting’ move on the 100th anniversary of ’s birth!
Meghan Markle is releasing two new candles (Image: Getty) Meghan Markle was criticised for releasing two new candles linked to her children, Prince Archie and Princess Lilibet,…
Cardi B threatens to scrap final show over venue staff’s ‘disrespectful’ behavior!
Cardi B in March 2026 in New York City Credit: Arturo Holmes/Getty NEED TO KNOW Cardi B almost called off…
SHOCKING: Meghan Markle caught on a secret ‘date’ with a ‘mystery’ man in Australia – Intimate photos exposed!
Meghan Markle was pictured with a friend in Australia last week (Image: GETTY) Meghan Markle reportedly met with her friend Markus Anderson…
End of content
No more pages to load






