If you’re a fan of Supernatural, you’ll likely agree that the first couple of seasons were the Golden Era for Sam and Dean Winchester, focusing on small-town monster hunting with a different creature each week. Now, Supernatural’s new series marks a return to the show’s greatest era.

For those unaware, Sam and Dean Winchester have returned in a brand-new comic series that launched this October with its first issue. Written by Greg Pak and illustrated by Eder Messias, Dynamite’s ongoing Supernatural comic series is set to release its third installment on December 17, 2025.

With only two issues out so far, the series has already distinguished itself by returning the franchise to peak form. Set between the first and second seasons of the TV show, this new chapter brings back the elements that made Supernatural a cult favorite, delivering everything fans loved about the original series.

Supernatural Returns to the Golden Era with a ‘Season 1.5’

Cover C Eder Messias Variant for Supernatural #1 (2025)

While opinions may vary, most Supernatural fans agree that Seasons 1–5 were the show’s golden era, with Season 5 praised for its epic Apocalypse storyline and perfect finale, Swan Song. What made the early seasons so beloved, however, were the largely self-contained stories that focused on small-town monster hunting, giving the show a mix of suspense and humor.

The early seasons largely followed a “monster of the week” format, introducing a new creature or threat in each episode, set in a different American town. This approach offered simplicity and variety, keeping each week fresh for viewers, and helped transform Supernatural into a sensational hit, building a dedicated fanbase that still celebrates the series’ unique blend of horror and brotherhood.

Dynamite’s Supernatural comic, set between Seasons 1 and 2, hits a sweet spot for fans, letting them relive the series’ golden years with brand-new content. Greg Pak’s first two issues have already proven to capture the feel of a true Season 1.5, blending nostalgia with fresh storytelling that honors what made the original show such a beloved phenomenon.

Dynamite’s Supernatural Feels Like Watching an Early Episode

Cover B David Cousens Variant for Supernatural #1 (2025)

For fans looking to relive Supernatural’s golden years but hesitant to rewatch the show for the fifth time, Dynamite’s comic series is a no-brainer. Issues #1 and #2 capture the feel of an original episode, presenting simple yet engaging mysteries that resolve neatly while retaining the charm, humor, and suspense that made the early seasons so memorable.

This is a major win for fans who felt disconnected from the later seasons, where storylines became overly complex, focusing on angels vs. demons, and world-ending events rather than the beloved monster-of-the-week adventures. For anyone craving a true Supernatural experience, the comic series delivers that perfect balance of nostalgia and fresh storytelling.