A Tiny Detail, Yet Its Impact Is Enough to Shock the Entire Audience – Guillermo del Toro’s Monster Deserves More Than One Chapter

Guillermo del Toro’s Frankenstein, now streaming on Netflix and still dominating theaters, has already been hailed as the most emotionally devastating adaptation of Mary Shelley’s classic ever made. Jacob Elordi’s towering, heartbreaking portrayal of the Creature has drawn comparisons to Boris Karloff and Robert De Niro, but one subtle costume detail—almost invisible on first viewing—has quietly become the internet’s obsession, and it’s the strongest argument yet for why this story cannot end here.

Look closely at the Creature’s left forearm. Beneath the layers of scarred, stitched flesh and del Toro’s signature grotesque beauty, there is a faint tattoo: a small, perfectly preserved rose with the initials “E. S.” in delicate script. It’s visible for exactly three frames during the moonlit scene when Victor (Oscar Isaac) first brings his creation to life and, later, in the heartbreaking moment when the Creature cradles Elizabeth’s body.

Fans quickly realized: E. S. stands for Elizabeth Shelley—Victor’s fiancée in the novel, and in del Toro’s version, the woman whose brain is secretly used to resurrect the Creature after her murder. The rose is the same flower Victor places in Elizabeth’s hair on their wedding day. In other words, the Creature literally carries a piece of Elizabeth’s soul etched into his skin—a tragic, poetic twist that confirms he is not just a monster, but a man reborn with the woman he was never allowed to love.

Del Toro himself confirmed the detail in a recent Variety interview: “The rose is the heart of the tragedy. He wakes up with her memories, her emotions, her love for Victor—trapped inside a body that can never express it. That single tattoo is why the story cannot end with him walking into the Arctic.”

The implications are staggering. Throughout the film, the Creature experiences flashes of tenderness, poetry, and rage that feel inexplicably human—because they are Elizabeth’s. When he weeps over her corpse, when he recites Shelley’s poetry, when he begs Victor, “Why did you make me remember her?”—it’s not just learned behavior. It’s her.

This revelation has sent social media into meltdown. #FrankensteinRose has 4.8 million posts, with fans editing slow-motion clips of the tattoo and writing essays titled “Elizabeth LIVES in the Monster.” One viral thread reads: “Del Toro didn’t just adapt Frankenstein—he gave us a love story that spans death itself. We NEED a sequel where the Creature confronts what’s left of Elizabeth inside him.”

Critics agree. The Hollywood Reporter called it “the most soul-shattering detail in modern horror,” while IndieWire wrote: “That rose is del Toro’s ultimate argument: the Creature isn’t a monster—he’s a haunted house with a heartbeat.”

Netflix has yet to confirm a sequel, but del Toro has been teasing “more stories in this world” since Cannes. With Frankenstein already the platform’s most-watched film of November (87 million hours in week one), the demand is deafening.

One tiny tattoo. Three frames. An entire argument for a sequel.

Watch Frankenstein again—pause at 01:12:47 and 02:03:11. You’ll never see the Creature the same way.

And you’ll understand why this story is far from over.