Netflix’s New Crime Comedy Big Mistakes Debuts With Rare Perfect Score

Netflix has another buzzy new series on its hands. The streamer’s latest crime-comedy Big Mistakes has arrived with an eye-catching milestone: a rare 100% critics score on Rotten Tomatoes, instantly putting the show on the radar of television fans and critics alike.

The eight-episode series is led by Dan Levy, who co-created the project alongside Rachel Sennott. For Levy, the show marks a significant return to television following the hugely successful run of Schitt’s Creek, which ended in 2020 after becoming a cultural phenomenon.

Although the perfect score is currently based on a small number of early reviews, the strong debut suggests the series could become one of Netflix’s most talked-about new crime shows if the positive momentum continues.

A Family Heist That Spirals Into Organized Crime

Premiering on April 9, Big Mistakes centers on siblings Nicky and Morgan, played by Levy and Taylor Ortega. What begins as a desperate attempt to help their dying grandmother quickly spirals into a dangerous situation far beyond anything they expected.

The siblings attempt a theft meant to solve their family’s problems, but instead find themselves pulled into the world of organized crime. Soon they are being blackmailed into increasingly risky jobs, forced to navigate criminals, schemes, and threats they barely understand.

Despite constantly being in over their heads, the pair somehow continue to stumble into success — creating a chaotic pattern of “failing upward” that drives the show’s dark humor and unpredictable twists.

A Star-Studded Supporting Cast

Beyond its central duo, Big Mistakes features a strong supporting ensemble led by veteran actress Laurie Metcalf. The cast also includes Abby Quinn, Boran Kuzum, Darren Goldstein, Elizabeth Perkins, Ilia Volok, Mark Ivanir, and several other familiar television faces.

The series also represents the first project released under Levy’s overall television deal with Netflix, making it an important step in his next creative chapter following the success of his previous work.

What Critics Are Saying

Early reactions from critics suggest that Big Mistakes delivers a unique mix of comedy, suspense, and crime storytelling.

Some reviewers note that the series can feel a bit chaotic, with its tone shifting between dark crime drama, fast-paced thriller, and quirky family comedy. However, many critics agree that the talented cast — particularly Levy and Ortega — helps carry the show through its more uneven moments.

Other reviews praise the show’s energetic pace, suspenseful plot developments, and surprising emotional depth, highlighting the way it blends comedic chaos with genuine stakes.

A Promising Start for Netflix’s New Series

For now, the rare perfect Rotten Tomatoes debut has given Big Mistakes a strong start in an increasingly crowded streaming landscape. Crime series remain one of television’s most dominant genres, and Netflix continues to invest heavily in shows that combine suspense with distinctive storytelling voices.

Whether the show’s score remains perfect as more critics weigh in remains to be seen. But one thing is already clear: Big Mistakes has arrived with enough buzz to become one of Netflix’s most closely watched new series of the year.